Exposing the GAPS Diet: Unverified Claims on Health and Weight Loss

nada - | Mix

Dr. Natasha Campbell-McBride introduced the Gut and Psychology Syndrome (GAPS) diet, designed to address various health issues, particularly neurological and digestive disorders, through specific dietary interventions. It has gained popularity among those seeking alternative treatments for conditions like dyslexia, ADHD, and autism. Proponents of the diet argue that it can assist in weight loss and enhance overall health. However, the GAPS diet's effectiveness remains controversial, as many experts question its scientific validity. This article critiques the GAPS diet, highlighting the lack of robust research supporting its health improvement and weight loss claims.

What Is the GAPS Diet?

The GAPS diet is a stringent nutritional regimen intended to repair the gut, which will enhance digestive and neurological function. It is predicated on the idea that a "leaky gut" has a role in a number of physical and mental health issues. There are three key phases to the diet:

  1. Introduction Diet: A highly restrictive phase intended to heal the gut lining through broths, fermented foods, and easily digestible proteins.
  2. Full GAPS Diet: Incorporates a broader range of foods, including vegetables, fruits, and non-gluten grains, while avoiding certain foods believed to aggravate gut health.
  3. Reintroduction: Gradually reintroduces foods to test tolerance and maintain gut health.

Claims Made by the GAPS Diet

The GAPS diet asserts several benefits, including:

  • Improved Digestive Health: By eliminating foods that allegedly cause gut irritation and incorporating gut-healing foods.
  • Enhanced Neurological Function: Based on the gut-brain axis theory, suggesting that gut health directly affects brain function.
  • Weight Loss: Through a diet low in processed foods and high in nutrient-dense options.

Scientific Scrutiny of GAPS Diet Claims

1. Digestive Health

Claim: The GAPS diet heals the gut lining, reduces inflammation, and alleviates symptoms of digestive disorders.


  • Current Understanding: While certain components of the GAPS diet, like bone broth and fermented foods, can support gut health, the diet’s restrictive nature lacks robust scientific validation.
  • Lack of Clinical Trials: There is a significant lack of controlled clinical trials or scientific studies confirming that the GAPS diet effectively treats digestive disorders.
  • Potential Risks: Restrictive diets may lead to nutritional deficiencies and exacerbate health issues if not properly managed.

Criticism: The diet’s reliance on anecdotal evidence and the absence of rigorous scientific studies undermines its credibility. Most claims are based on personal testimonials rather than empirical data.

2. Neurological Function

Claim: The GAPS diet improves neurological function by addressing gut dysbiosis, which purportedly contributes to conditions like autism and ADHD.


  • Gut-Brain Axis: While emerging research supports the gut-brain axis's role in mental health, the direct impact of the GAPS diet on neurological conditions lacks substantial evidence.
  • No Direct Correlation: Current scientific literature does not establish a direct correlation between the diet and significant improvements in neurological conditions.

Criticism: The theory that diet alone can treat complex neurological conditions is oversimplified. Experts argue that while diet can influence overall health, it should not replace conventional medical treatments for neurological disorders.

3. Weight Loss

Claim: The GAPS diet aids in weight loss through its emphasis on natural, whole foods and the elimination of processed items.


  • Healthy Eating Principles: The diet’s focus on whole foods aligns with general principles of healthy eating, which can contribute to weight loss.
  • Caloric Restriction: The restrictive nature of the diet may inadvertently lead to calorie reduction, which could result in weight loss.

Criticism: Weight loss may occur due to reduced calorie intake rather than any unique aspect of the diet itself. The restrictive nature may also make it difficult to sustain long-term, leading to potential weight regain.

Potential Risks and Downsides

1. Nutritional Deficiencies

The GAPS diet’s restrictive nature can lead to nutritional imbalances. Key concerns include deficiencies in:

  • Carbohydrates: Essential for energy, particularly in active individuals.
  • Fiber: Important for digestive health; the exclusion of certain grains and legumes can reduce fiber intake.
  • Micronutrients: Vitamins and minerals found in excluded foods may not be adequately replaced by allowed foods.

2. Dietary Sustainability

Maintaining the GAPS diet long-term can be challenging due to:

  • Restrictive Guidelines: The need to avoid many common foods can make the diet socially and practically difficult to adhere to.
  • Cost and Preparation: The diet often requires significant time and financial investment in preparing specific foods like bone broths and fermented items.

3. Lack of Medical Supervision

Implementing the GAPS diet without professional guidance can pose risks, especially for:

  • Children and Adolescents: Who have higher nutritional needs for growth and development.
  • Individuals with Medical Conditions: Who may have specific dietary requirements that the GAPS diet does not address.

Expert Opinions on the GAPS Diet

Many nutrition experts and healthcare professionals express skepticism about the GAPS diet due to:

  • Lack of Scientific Validation: The diet's theories are not supported by substantial clinical evidence.
  • Anecdotal Basis: The reliance on personal stories rather than controlled studies limits its credibility.
  • Potential Health Risks: The restrictive nature of the diet can lead to imbalances and deficiencies if not carefully managed.

Alternative Approaches

For those seeking dietary interventions for health improvement, evidence-based alternatives include:

  • Balanced Diet: Emphasizing a variety of whole foods, including fruits, vegetables, lean proteins, and whole grains.
  • Mediterranean Diet: Known for its cardiovascular benefits and supported by extensive research.
  • Consultation with Professionals: Working with a registered dietitian or healthcare provider to develop a personalized, balanced eating plan.


Although the GAPS diet is well-liked in some circles, there isn't enough solid scientific data to support its claims about brain function, weight loss, and digestive health. Because of its restrictions, there may be dangers and difficulties, especially when trying to achieve a balanced diet. It is advised that people thinking about changing their diets for better health look for evidence-based strategies and expert advice. Eating a varied, well-balanced diet full of nutrients is still a good way to promote general health and wellbeing.
People may prioritize sustainable and scientifically-supported dietary habits above unproven claims by making educated decisions about their health and nutrition by being aware of the drawbacks and possible dangers of diets like the GAPS.

About Author

45 Total posts

Read Also

Dubai awards contract for entrances and exits to Dubai Harbor area project

The infrastructure development at Dubai Harbour, spearheaded by the RTA in coordination with Shamal Holding, reflects Dubai's commitment to enhancing urban development and accommodating population growth. This project will significantly improve...

UAE Court imposes a 6-month internet network ban to an Arab man for this reason

In a legal case that highlights the complexities of defamation via digital communication, a Dubai court has ruled in favor of compensation for psychological harm caused by a voice message sent over WhatsApp.

UAE: MoPH launches Health and Nutrition Survey 2024-2025

The Ministry of Health and Community Protection has launched the National Health and Nutrition Survey Campaign 2024-2025 in partnership with the Federal Center for Competitiveness and Statistics, local health agencies, and statistics centres across...

Emirates unveils Wimbledon sponsorship with live tennis and in-flight indulgence

Emirates, which is well-known for providing opulent air travel, has entered the tennis scene with a major move when it was named The Championships, Wimbledon's Official Airline Partner.

Abu Dhabi Authority introduces free summer activities for retirees and families

The "Abu Dhabi Sports Summer" initiative, spearheaded by ADNEC Services Company, has the full support of the Abu Dhabi Retirement Fund.

UAE denies claims of Emirati passports found 'on Sudan battlefield'

The United Arab Emirates has categorically denied any allegations of Emirati participation in the ongoing conflict in Sudan.

UAE launches new service to help buyers check accident history of used cars

Searching for a used vehicle? Also, asking friends and family for a ride? An absolute necessity in these cases would be to research the vehicle's history in order to learn about its current state and any accidents it may have been involved in.

UAE launches 5 training programs with financial aid for private sector citizens

The UAE Talent Competitiveness Council (NAFES) has launched five transformative training programs aimed at bolstering the capabilities and competitiveness of Emirati nationals within the private sector.

All the information you need regarding the US presidential debate

In what promises to be a close rematch for the White House in November, US President Joe Biden and US President Donald Trump will square off on a debate stage on Thursday for the first of two televised face-offs.

Iranian election dropout Amir Ghazizadeh was the first competitor to do so.

Late on Wednesday, a contender in Iran's presidential contest announced his withdrawal from the contest. This made him the first to pull out, allowing hardliners to unite behind a unity candidate in the race to succeed the late President Ebrahim...

UAE MoHRE announces new video support service via mobile app

The Ministry of Human Resources and Emiratisation (MoHRE) in the UAE has introduced a video call service through its official smart application, alongside continuing to offer this feature via WhatsApp at the number 600 590000.

UAE Ministry strongly denounces terrorist attacks in Dagestan

The UAE's Ministry of Foreign Affairs has unequivocally condemned recent terrorist attacks in Dagestan, Russia, denouncing these acts of violence that claimed the lives of security personnel and innocent civilians. The UAE extended heartfelt...

UAE: Filipino Leaders Deny Rumors of "166 HIV-Positive OFWs" in Dubai

Expats in the UAE have been cautioned against spreading fake news, a severe offense that can result in a fine of up to Dh200,000 and imprisonment.

Why did Julian Assange get into so much trouble because of WikiLeaks?

After a 14-year legal battle, Julian Assange, the creator of the whistleblower media organization WikiLeaks, is expected to reach a plea agreement this week that would release him from prison and enable him to return to Australia.

Americans intend to watch CNN debate between Biden and Trump majority.

A new survey from The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research indicates that the majority of US adults plan to watch at least part of Thursday's presidential debate and that many believe the event will be significant for the...

"Leg Day Routine: Achieve Massive Thighs with This Intense Workout"

Achieving strong and well-defined thighs is a common fitness goal that not only enhances your physique but also boosts your overall strength and performance. A well-designed leg day routine can help you build massive thighs by targeting key muscle...

Dubai declares the completion of traffic improvements on major roads

Dubai's Roads and Transport Authority (RTA) recently concluded extensive road improvement projects aimed at alleviating congestion and enhancing traffic flow in the bustling Al Mankhool area.

Dubai Police Offer Military Training and Horse Riding Lessons for Students

Dubai Police is set to launch summer courses on July 1, targeting students aged 11 to 18. These courses, spanning scuba diving, horseback riding, and military training, are open to students from both private and public schools, irrespective of...

UAE announce new short vocational education program for underperforming students

Students who did not do well in school but would still like to get vocational training can now do so through a new "career accelerator track" at a college in Dubai.

UAE Pensions Authority launches Improved Registration Process

As part of its continuous efforts to improve its services, the General Authority for Pensions and Social Security has made major enhancements to the insured's registration service.

Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid announces approval of 2,160 housing decisions